Naples: Life, Death & Miracles  © 2002-2017       contact:     Jeff Matthews  
home & index 1     -->  2
 welcome 
 sitemap
portals
map
other
eyes of
venues
photos/
audio

history
ErN
museums
sardinia
link to a Google search page HERE
main index                 © Jeff Matthews                                      entry Sept. 2011, revised Apr 2017

early example of earthquake-resistant construction and modern urban planning

The Earthquake of 1783 and the Rebuilding of Calabria

"Foundation” Cities   - box added Apr 12, 2017  

   This page documents the modern methods of new anti-seismic building techniques and the construction of new communities and rebuilding of others in Calabria after the earthquake of 1783.

   In Italian, the term città di fondazione [foundation city] is commonly called in English a planned community or city, or new city. (Some of them may even be named “new city” in various places around the world.) By definition, such communities are carefully planned from their inception and typically built in previously undeveloped areas. Often they are built relatively quickly and in response to an immediate need. This, as opposed to traditional settlements that grow naturally in a more helter-skelter fashion over longer periods of time. There have been hundreds of such planned communities throughout the world over the centuries. They are usually symmetrical in some fashion, possibly circular such as Baghdad (built in 790s) or grid-like such as virtually all of the cities of Magna Graecia (such as Naples, alias Neapolis or New City), the streets running perfectly north to south and east to west to form city blocks. They may be ancient such as the cities of Magna Graecia (Paestum, for example) and those of the Indus Valley civilization or modern such as New York City or Brasilia.

   The Foundation Cities, the planned communities, of Calabria were built in response to the immediate need to recover from one of the worst earthquakes in recorded history. The recover was not done hastily; the Neapolitan crown spent almost three years before beginning actual construction, three years of assembling an army of engineers and architects and of studying previous models: the rebuilding of eastern Sicily after the serious quake of 1693, the Lisbon quake of 1755 and other foreign models such as the Edinburgh of architect James Craig. Then they went ahead. By any standard the task was monumental. The result was a collection of about a dozen towns in the south that were modern, orderly (but not monotonous), and aesthetic. Indeed, the planners allowed for eccentricities to accommodate even new seaside communities such as Bagnara Calabra (or, simply, Bagnara) (original plan, above right) on the hills facing the Tyrrhenian Sea on the southern tip of the region of Reggio Calabria, just above the city of that name. (It's still there after 235 years of anything but peaceful history. Current population, just over 10,000). The totality of these planned communities even influenced the majestically ambitious and less hurried construction going on in Naples, the capital city of the kingdom, as the Bourbon monarchy set about to build its own "Foundation" city, a new capital with the "Italian Versaille," the grand palace of Caserta, as the centerpiece. Political events overtook both the cities of the south and Naples a few decades later, but the urban planning and subsequent construction in both cases were impressive.



The massive earthquake in Lisbon in 1755 produced a striking piece of anonymous verse:

With her last earthquake this round world shall rise,
 The sun shall lose his fires in endless night,
 And the moon turned to blood, glare horrid light,
 When comets dire shall sweep athwart the sky,
 And stars like leaves before the tempest fly.

That horrible event brought comments from Voltaire, Rousseau, and even Kant, who opined that people should stop blaming such things on a wrathful god and worry more about putting up houses that can withstand earthquakes. (A wise man, old Manny.) And so, after all was said and done, the Lisbon quake, indeed, produced a new kind of construction, gaiola pombalina (Pombaline cage, named for the Marquês de Pombal, instrumental in rebuilding Lisbon)—that is, masonry building reinforced with an internal wooden cage.

Design of casa baraccata bracing, from
Vivenzio's Istoria de' Tremuoti (1783)
Lisbon was a major historic capital and one of the most beautiful cities in Europe; thus, news of the earthquake spread fast (for those days) and was the focus of attention throughout the Continent. On the other hand, the calamitous earthquakes that struck Calabria in the southern region of the Kingdom of Naples in 1783 were in an area so remote that news of the disaster took nine days to get back to the royal palace in the capital city, Naples, a few hundred miles to the north.

The first of five major quakes struck on February 5, 1783, but later research revealed that the entire region had been hit by a series of quakes lasting through 1787. All in all, 949 major and minor quakes hit Calabria. Around 200 cities and towns were destroyed. The estimated number of deaths ranges from 32,000 to 50,000. The very landscape of Calabria was changed as new valleys and lakes were created. Pietro Colleta, a prominent Neapolitan historian from the time, wrote in his Storia del Reame di Napoli [History of the Kingdom of Naples], “Nothing remained of the old forms; lands, cities, roads, signs vanished…Many works of nature and man, built over the centuries…were in a moment destroyed."


Much of the history of the Kingdom of Naples in the 1700s tends to be overwhelmed by later political events leading up to the unification of Italy (1860). Certainly there does not seem to be an awareness even in Calabria today of the major natural catastrophes in the 1780s (in the way, for example, that Portuguese still remember the 1755 event). The Calabrian calamity, as far as I know, produced no dramatic poetry. The good news is that it certainly produced no Neapolitan counterpart of the earlier Lisbon episodes of people being burned at the stake to appease the Lord! (*note) The Calabrian disaster did, however, produce some things that are noteworthy in the history of science, engineering and urban planning. The Bourbon government sent out a research team from the Neapolitan Academy of Science and Letters and quickly published a remarkable work, Istoria de' fenomeni del tremoto avvenuto nelle Calabrie e nel Valdemone nell'anno 1783 [Account of the Effects of the Earthquake in Calabria in 1783]. The catastrophes thus led to innovation in architecture and construction. Tobriner (sources, below) writes:
The Bourbon government...introduced a system of construction to minimize future damage and to save lives. The building system, called la casa baraccate, was based on the sophisticated notion that structures must respond to seismic disturbances as units. The system was based on an internal framework of wood members embedded in the rubble construction which was common in Calabria. Height limitations, foundations, and special "x" bracing to counter lateral forces were also part of the system that was invented in Calabria and promulgated as the construction code of 1785. It represents one of the earliest concerted responses to earthquake danger and one which was lauded by early 20th-century engineers as a practical means of providing safe construction in earthquake country.

Much of the original work was written up by the royal physician, Giovanni Vivenzio, in Istoria de' Tremuoti (1783). The work contains a diagram of the anti-seismic casa baraccata system of construction (top photo), detailing how it is different from the gaiola system used in Portugal 30 years earlier. (From Tobriner 2, sources, below): "The system works upon the basic principle that the masonry structure is tied together by an internal wooden framework. But whereas the lateral resistance of the gaiola is in the internal walls, the lateral resistance in the casa baraccata is in the external walls."



The casa baraccata and the new building code of 1785 that came out of the work of Vivenzio and others represent the first anti-seismic system in Europe prescribed by code for an entire region. Numerous new towns were built to the new 1785 building code, including the town of Filadelfia (to replace the ruined town of Castelmonardo). Filadelfia, in particular, was an attempt to create an ideal community (perhaps somewhat like the earlier social experiment by Charles III to create a perfect rural community at San Leucio in 1750). Filadelfia and other towns were built or rebuilt with the Cassa Sacra, funds appropriated from the Catholic church (note 2). The Bourbon state limited the number of churches that a new town could have (and even forbade church steeples!); the streets were laid out symmetrically and the buildings were uniform.



Seminara, rebuilt according to the new          
building code of 1785, typical of the new          
planned communities of Calabria          

The modern Italian region of Calabria has five provinces as indicated (map, above). Filadelfia is in the smallest province, Vito Valentia. Of the many towns rebuilt or built new after the 1783 earthquakes, a few stand out as having been done to the regulations of the new building code, which specified (according to population) how wide main and secondary streets should be, how tall the buildings could be, specifying placement of public fountains, churches, market squares, parks, etc. Also, effort was made to save historic structures that had not been totally destroyed by the quakes. The new towns include Bianco (RC), Seminara (RC), Mileto (VV), Gallina (RC), Cortale (Cat), Bagnara (RC), and, as noted, Filadelfia (VV). They and others all have things in common: they are all relatively small in population (Calabria was a great exporter of human beings during the Neapolitan diaspora of the late 1800s and early 1900s), and even today there is something modern about these towns from the late 18th century in that there is no medieval clutter, there is a main square, and there are straight streets. All of that is the result of having been part of the first massive effort in European history to build not just single buildings, but entire towns that could withstand the seismic forces of nature and then to re-incorporate an entire region back into a modern nation state.

[insert paragraph from the bio of Pompeo Schianterelli
April 2017]

     An engraved plate from the Istoria.
Most interesting in the prolific career of Pompeo Schianterlli is an episode only tangentially connected to architecture, having more to do with geology. The great Lisbon earthquake of 1755 produced the first example in Europe of technical diagrammatic illustrations of the effects of such a disaster (by British natural philosopher John Michell and the Dutchman Johan Drijfhout). When southern Italy’s turn came in 1783—a series of calamitous quakes that killed 35,000 persons and devastated much of Calabria—the Neapolitan Academy of Science and Letters sent a team to record the devastation. Destruction of man-made structures as well as topographical changes to the environment were recorded on the scene with the aim of providing accurate and comprehensive visual documentation. Pompeo Schiantarelli led the team, and his 68 sketches (the engraving for printing the plates was done by Ignazio Stile) with fold-out plates and maps recorded in Istoria de' fenomeni del tremoto avvenuto nelle Calabrie e nel Valdemone nell'anno 1783 [Account of the Effects of the Earthquake in Calabria in 1783] (pub. Naples, 1784) are early examples of a pragmatic blend of art and scientific observation. At least two Calabrian towns, Polistena and Mileto, destroyed by the earthquake were rebuilt to plans laid out by Schiantarelli. (The plates and text of the earthquake account are widely cited and have been reprinted. They are thoroughly discussed in “Sections and Views: Visual Representation in Eighteenth-Century Earthquake Studies” by Susanne B. Keller in The British Journal for the History of Science, Vol. 31, No. 2 (June, 1998), Cambridge University Press.) I think there is only one book about Schiantarelli: Pompeo Schiantarelli. Ricerca ed architettura nel secondo settecento napoletano [Research and Architecture in Naples in the late 18th Century], by Francesco Divenuto (pub. Edizione Scientifiche Italiane, 1984).


notes:
1. In Candide (1759), Voltaire wrote, “After the earthquake, which had destroyed three-fourths of the city of Lisbon, the sages of that country could think of no means more effectual to preserve the kingdom from utter ruin than to entertain the people with an auto-da-fé, it having been decided by the University of Coimbra, that the burning of a few people alive by a slow fire, and with great ceremony, is an infallible preventive of earthquakes.”  In fairness, Voltaire's buddy, Rousseau, accused him of being unduly cynical and snide. Cynical? Snide? Who, Voltaire?! (^back)


2. The town of Filadelfia apparently comes to its interesting name from the fact that the bishop of nearby Potenza at the time was Giovanni Andrea Serrao. He was born in Castelmnonardo and was a great promoter of building a new town to replace his birthplace, now destroyed. He also thought it would be a good idea if citizens remembered their Greek origins and lived in a place the name of which would remind them to love each other and all humanity ("phila-delphia"= a compound of philos (φίλος) "loving", and adelphos (ἀδελφός) "brother"). ANDvery important—Serrao had been corresponding with a resident of the other City of Brotherly Love, Benjamin Franklin!   (^back)


other sources:

- Principe, Ilario. Città nuove in Calabria nel tardo Settecento [New Cities in Calabria in the Late 1700s]. Chiaravalle Centrale (CZ), 1976.
-Romano, Marco. "Le Città di Fondazione dopo il 1783" in Dentro l'Italia; Piccole città, borghi e villagi. volume 3 Sud. pub. by Touring Club Italiano, 2008.
- Tobriner, Stephen. "La Casa Baraccata: Earthquake-Resistant Construction in 18th-Century Calabria," in Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians, Vol. 42, No. 2.
Pub. by U. of California Press (May, 1983).
-
Tobriner, Stephen. "Safety and Reconstruction After the Sicilian earthquake of 1693--the Eighteenth-Century Context" in Dreadful Visitations: Confronting Natural catastrophe in the Age of Enlightenment by Alessa Johns, Routledge, 1999.
- unsigned .pdf file online here: Le Città della Calabrie Ricostruite dopo il Terremoto del 1783. Retr. Sept. 4, 2011.


to main index       to portal for architecure & urban planning